software development: scrum vs waterfall

Offshore software development: scrum vs waterfall comparison

Tips / Software development

Offshore software development: scrum vs waterfall comparison

There are various methodologies in software development: Agile, DevOps deployment, Waterfall, Scrum, etc. But how can business owners identify which method is most suitable for their software development project? In this following article, TECHVIFY Vietnam will analyze and compare 2 software development methodologies: Scrum and Waterfall.

An overview comparison:

In our previous articles, we have introduced some basic information about how the Scrum process and Waterfall process work. So here are the main differences between these two software development methodologies:

ScrumWaterfall
Value-drivenSchedule driven
Development is iterative and incrementalDevelopment is phase-based and sequential
It includes customers and stakeholders at each phaseThe customers only involve in the very last steps, when the result is near
A cross-functional team with knowledge of the product invested in the whole team through shared experiencesHandovers between analyses-design-build-test phases with knowledge stored in documents            Cross-functional team with knowledge of the
Offer time and money efficiency by reviewing regular sprints in the development processRequire extra time because reviewing is only done at the last step
Work is divided into teams as an individual responsibility.Work is divided into phases. The team works closely.
The customer is kept in the loop for feedback throughout the process of developmentThe required documentation is done at the initial stage
Suitable for difficult and complex projectsSuitable for smaller projects
It has no defined stagesThe stages are clearly defined from the beginning
Adapt very quickly to changes throughout the processChanges are only welcomed at the requirement phase
The development process is divided into smaller stages to work withPhases and processes are completed respectively
It divides its work into sprints and then assigned according to team membersIt divides its work into stages and the process continues one after the other
Not bound by a tight deadlineHave to strictly follow a tight deadline

Advantages and disadvantages of the Waterfall process:

To understand more thoroughly, we will find out the advantages and disadvantages of each method.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Before the next phase of development, each phase must be completed.The linear project plan is rigid and lacks flexibility for adapting to unexpected events.
Suited for smaller projects where requirements are well defined.It is not desirable for a complex project where requirement changes frequently.
Perfect quality assurance tests have to be done before completing each stage.The testing period comes quite late in the process and errors can only be fixed during the phase.
Elaborate documentation is done at every phase of the software’s development cycle.Documentation occupies a lot of time of developers and testers
The project is completely dependent on a project team with minimum client intervention.Clients cannot give feedback during the process. Small changes or errors that arise in the completed software may cause a lot of problems and money to go back and design the code again.
Project requirements are agreed upon in the first phase, so planning and scheduling are simple and clear.It might be difficult for customers to specify all of their needs at the beginning of the project
With a fully laid-out project schedule, you can give accurate estimates for your project cost, resources, and deadlines.

 

Advantages and disadvantages of the Scrum process:

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Quickly adapt to changesThe final product can be different because of too many changes during the process
The working efforts of the team member can be measured individuallyTeam members have to be skillful enough to bring out the best result
It saves time because the chances of errors are lessThe conflict between team members can threaten the deadline
Scrum provides flexibility for changes in the product during any stageMany changes during software development can cause a delay in the process because of an increase in the amount of work
The customer will be able to see the working software before the final deliveryDocumentation might be neglected because the developing team only care about general documents that can support the software development process
Simple planning makes the process more flexible and easy to managePlanning can be less concrete
Constant communication and interaction with the customer are priorities over the process and tools.

 

Now that you’ve learned the differences between Scrum and Waterfall, as well as the benefits of each method, it’s time to decide which approach would be best suited for your project. Depending on your project’s needs, your final choice should give the best results for the time and money spent.

TECHVIFY is an offshore software development team that has experience in consulting the most suitable developing model for businesses.

So if you are a business owner who is confused because of various software developing methodologies, leave your information below and we will get in touch shortly to discuss technology solutions for your business.

Discover more in our new articles about offshore software development:  Offshore software development: How does Scrum best work in the process?